Best Pizza in Oak Lawn, IL

It may be easy to find a pizza place in Oak Lawn, but sometimes it takes a tip from a Evergreen Park local to find the very best. We’re staffed with Orland Park locals at Oak Lawn Toyota, so we made a list of the best pizza Oak Lawn has to offer. Check out our top five pizza places in Oak Lawn, and make sure you don’t miss our Local Guide for more tips on the best Oak Lawn restaurants, shopping, and more!

Palermo’s 95th Italian Cuisine

Family-owned since opening over 35 years back, Palermo’s on 95th remains a local favorite — even while making a name for itself all across the Orland Park area. The rustic dining area has an old-world charm, and that sense of history is imbued in many of their traditional family recipes as well. However, a major part of Palermo’s broad appeal comes from the fact that they offer both new and old. On their menu, you’ll find modern Italian specials alongside old-world favorites, and something to please the whole family. Without a doubt, this is the best pizza in Oak Lawn.

Palermo's on 95th

Grassano’s Pizza

You should head to this casual eatery for the pizza, of course — but for something different, we recommend Grassano’s pizza puffs! You can get your homemade giant pizza puff filled with any topping you’d put on a pizza — sausage, green pepper, mushrooms, pepperoni, ground beef, spinach, pineapple, and more. Plus, puffs are easy to take with you on the go!


Phil’s Pizza

If you like your pizza heavy on the toppings, then we have to recommend Phil’s. Established in 1977, this casual, family-owned pizzeria is known far and wide for “the meatiest, the cheesiest, and the sauciest” pizza around! Phil’s offers catering for your Oak Lawn events, as well as delivery to your home in the surrounding areas like Countryside.


Nonna’s Pizza

At Nonna’s, they say they don’t need to tell you why their pizza is the best — you just need to try it for yourself. Nonna’s traditional family recipes are passed down through the generations. The dough is made fresh in-house, and they serve an awesome gelato for dessert. But maybe the most important thing to know is that they’re open till 3 a.m., 7 days a week!

Nonna's Pizza

Check Us Out for More of Oak Lawn’s Best!

Reach out to us with any questions about the best Orland Park shopping, family fun, and restaurants in Oak Lawn, and you can even learn more about our favorite escape rooms — at Oak Lawn Toyota we’ve got you covered!

More From Oak Lawn Toyota

  • 2020 Toyota Highlander Colors

    The 2020 Toyota Highlander is well-known in Oak Lawn for it’s driver-friendly MSRP and it’s suite of interior features for your long road trips or your Evergreen Park commute. However, the Toyota Highlander also comes with a variety of color options for drivers to choose from. With eight exterior colors and four interior colors, drivers can customize…

  • Oak Lawn Toyota’s Updated Hours for June 2020

    Oak Lawn Toyota Updates Customers on Latest Hours and Procedures for June 2020 as Illinois Enters Phase Three of the Restore Illinois Plan May 28, 2020 A Message from Ronnie Colosimo, CEO & President, Oak Lawn Toyota Expanded Hours for Service and Sales Departments. A maximum number of customers allowed in each building at a…

  • Toyota Brings Back the Venza Crossover for 2021

    Toyota Brings Back the Two-Row Crossover Utility Vehicle with the All-New 2021 Venza The All-New 2021 Toyota Venza combines an elegant design with cutting-edge tech and comfort. It comes equipped exclusively with the Toyota Hybrid II powertrain and advanced Electronic On-Demand All-Wheel Drive. Built to impress on the highway and in the city, the Venza…

Image Sources:

Contact Us


Call Now

4320 W 95th Street • Oak Lawn, IL 60453

Get Directions

Today's Hours:

Open Today! Sales: 9am-5am

Open Today! Service: 7:30am-4pm

Open Today! Parts: 7:30am-4pm

Oak Lawn Toyota 41.7207902, -87.7296311.