The Pre-Owned Toyota SUV Guide

When shopping for a dependable, value-packed SUV in the pre-owned market, Toyota is often the first name that comes to mind. Two of the most popular models on the road are the RAV4 and the Highlander. Both boast Toyota’s legendary reliability, but they are built for very different needs.

The Toyota RAV4 is the athletic, agile compact crossover perfect for city life and small families. The Toyota Highlander is its larger, three-row sibling, designed to carry bigger crews and more cargo in greater comfort. Choosing between a pre-owned RAV4 and a used Highlander comes down to a simple question: what does your daily life demand? This guide will break down their key differences to help you decide.

View Inventory

Features, Space, and Performance Comparison

While both are excellent SUVs, their designs serve distinct purposes. Here’s how they stack up in the areas that matter most.

• Vehicle Size and Maneuverability: The most obvious difference is size. The RAV4 is a compact crossover. Its smaller footprint makes it a dream for navigating tight city streets, parallel parking, and zipping through traffic. The Highlander is a midsize SUV. That larger size means more interior room, but it can be more challenging to maneuver in crowded urban areas.
• Passenger Seating and Cargo Capacity: These are often the deciding factors. The RAV4 is a two-row SUV that seats up to five passengers, making it ideal for individuals, couples, and small families. The Highlander features three rows of seating and can accommodate up to eight passengers (depending on the configuration), which is a necessity for larger families.
  • For cargo, the RAV4 offers impressive space for its class, with about 37–38 cubic feet behind the rear seats and up to 70 cubic feet with them folded.
  • The Highlander has less space behind its third row (as little as 16 cubic feet), but its maximum volume is far greater, reaching around 84 cubic feet with all rear seats folded down.
• Performance, Efficiency, and Towing: The RAV4 prioritizes efficiency, while the Highlander focuses on power.
  • RAV4: Newer models typically feature a 2.5L four-cylinder engine (around 203 horsepower post-2023) that offers excellent fuel efficiency. For maximum MPG, RAV4 Hybrid models are generally more efficient than their Highlander Hybrid counterparts.
  • Highlander: Newer models come with a more powerful engine, like a 2.4L turbocharged four-cylinder (265 hp and 310 pounds-feet of torque post-2023). This power gives it a significant towing capacity of up to 5,000 pounds (when properly equipped), far exceeding the RAV4’s 3,500-pound limit. The Highlander also provides a smoother, quieter ride, making it more comfortable for long road trips.
• Interior and Technology: Inside, the RAV4 leans toward durability and practicality, with hard-wearing materials built to last. The Highlander, especially in higher trims, offers a more premium and luxurious feel with higher-quality materials. While both include modern tech, the Highlander often has more available high-end options, like a head-up display or Driver Easy Speak.

View Inventory

Best Years for Pre-Owned RAV4s

When searching for a pre-owned RAV4, certain model years stand out. The fourth generation, spanning 2013–2018, is widely cited as a sweet spot for its combination of reliability and great value. In particular, the 2018 model, which was the final year of that generation, is highly praised for its dependability.

If you’re looking for the best value that also includes modern safety features, models from 2016–2018 are an excellent choice, as this is when the Toyota Safety Sense suite became standard. For those prioritizing maximum fuel economy, the newer fifth-generation hybrids from 2020–2022 offer the best of both worlds, combining advanced technology with excellent MPG.

View Inventory

Best Years for Pre-Owned Highlanders

For the pre-owned Highlander, a few key periods offer outstanding value. Models from 2016–2018, part of the third generation, provide a fantastic balance of modern features, available safety technology, and proven reliability.

Suppose you are on a stricter budget and prioritize rock-solid dependability above all else. In that case, the 2007 model—the last of the first generation—is a highly regarded and affordable option, though it lacks modern tech. For buyers seeking the latest features, models from 2020–2022 represent the newest generation; these vehicles feature a complete redesign, the most up-to-date technology, a modern interior, and improved fuel efficiency on the hybrid models.

View Inventory

Your Perfect Pre-Owned Toyota Awaits

The choice between a used RAV4 and a used Highlander is clear: If you need an agile, efficient, and capable five-seater, the RAV4 is your perfect match. If your life demands more power, more seats, and more premium comfort for a larger crew, the Highlander is the clear winner.

The best way to know for sure is to get behind the wheel. We have a fantastic selection of high-quality, pre-owned RAV4 and Highlander models ready for you to explore. We invite you to book a test drive online and visit Oak Lawn Toyota today!

View Inventory